Hi everyone,
My Flutter app keeps getting rejected by Google Play under the Broken Functionality policy because of this error on the reviewer's device: "The item that you were attempting to purchase could not be found." The reviewer's screenshot shows our paywall with a loading spinner, then Google's purchase sheet with that error (screenshots attached).
What Google's emails said:
1. First rejection (when I sent the app to production after completing 14 days of closed testing): "Violation of Broken Functionality policy... Unresponsive UI elements, such as buttons or icons", with the reviewer's screenshot attached.
2. After I appealed with a screen recording: the appeal was denied. The reply said the app "still violates" the policy, and that the "Subscribe Now" button is "not responsive or leads to an error page."
Neither email says which device, account or country the reviewer used.
My setup:
- Flutter app with RevenueCat, two subscriptions: yearly and weekly
- Both subscriptions and their base plans are Active in Play Console
- The yearly base plan is available in all countries, and the Production track is available in all countries too
- Purchases work in internal testing and in closed testing
- I also tested on my OPPO device and the purchase works
- I attached a video of the working purchase flow with my appeal, but it was still rejected
Questions:
1. Has anyone had the same error only on reviewers' devices while it works for testers? What fixed it?
2. Reviewers seem to use accounts that aren't license testers. Is there any setup or configuration that makes the purchase work for them?
3. The error dialog comes from Google's purchase sheet before my code can handle the failure. Is there any way to prevent it, or to avoid the "unresponsive" finding?
4. Has anyone passed review by resubmitting a new version (for example with a free path, or a different paywall flow) instead of appealing again?
Any help is appreciated, and I can share more details if needed. Thanks!

